Where informal action has not resolved the issue, or where the matter is serious enough to warrant immediate formal action, the following disciplinary procedure steps must be followed, in compliance with the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures. Failure to follow these steps can increase any compensation award by up to 25% at tribunal.
A disciplinary investigation must be carried out by an impartial person, ideally someone not involved in the allegations, to assess whether there is a case to answer. The investigation involves gathering evidence, taking witness statements, reviewing documentation, and forming a view on whether the matter should proceed to a formal hearing. The investigator's findings should be documented in a written report before any decision to proceed is made.
The employee must receive written notification of the hearing - setting out the nature of the allegations, the evidence to be considered, and the possible outcomes including dismissal where relevant. The ACAS Code requires that this notice is given with reasonable advance notice (typically at least 48 hours) and confirms the employee's right to be accompanied by a trade union representative or workplace colleague.
The formal disciplinary hearing is where the employer presents the evidence and the employee is given the opportunity to respond, ask questions, and present any mitigating circumstances. The hearing must be chaired by someone not involved in the investigation. A note-taker should be present. The employee's companion may confer with them but cannot answer questions on their behalf. The chair should not make a decision during the hearing itself.
Following the hearing, the employer must reach a decision and communicate it to the employee in writing. Possible outcomes include: no further action; a first written warning; a final written warning; demotion; or dismissal. The outcome letter must set out the reason for the decision, any improvement required, the duration of any warning, and the right to appeal. Sanctions must be proportionate to the seriousness of the offence and consistent with how similar cases have been handled.
Employees have the right to appeal any disciplinary decision. The ACAS Code requires that the right to appeal is offered in all cases, failing to provide an appeal route can render an otherwise fair dismissal procedurally unfair. Appeals should be heard by a manager more senior than the original decision-maker, ideally someone who was not involved in the original hearing or investigation.
The appeal outcome is final. The appeal chair considers whether the original decision was reasonable and proportionate given the evidence. They can uphold the original decision, vary it (for example, reduce a final warning to a first warning), or overturn it entirely. The outcome must be communicated to the employee in writing and represents the end of the internal disciplinary process.
You would be likely to begin the process if you felt that the employees behaviour is not compatible with the business ethos and working practise that is expected. Reasons for initiating one may include,
Not every performance or conduct issue requires a formal disciplinary action. Where the issue is minor, a first occurrence, or where the employee may be unaware their behaviour is problematic, an informal conversation is typically the right first step. An informal chat allows the employer to raise concerns early, give the employee the opportunity to improve, and demonstrate to any future tribunal that a proportionate approach was taken before escalating to formal proceedings.
Even at the informal stage, it is important to make a written record of what was discussed, what was agreed, and any timescales for improvement. If the matter does escalate, this documentation demonstrates that the employer provided adequate opportunity for the employee to address the issue before formal proceedings began. Harwood HR advises employers on when informal action is appropriate and how to document it correctly.
Our formal disciplinary procedure starts by investigating the issue. We inform the employee, allowing them to discuss the issue and present their side of the story. Depending on the findings, a hearing may follow where disciplinary decisions range from a verbal warning to a final written warning, or in serious cases, dismissal.
Our approach adheres to the ACAS Code of Practice, ensuring that all actions, from issuing a written warning to providing a chance to appeal, are legally sound. We also ensure compliance with health and safety rules, essential to our disciplinary and grievance procedures.
With Harwood HR, you have peace of mind knowing you have expert HR consulting guiding you through complex employment tribunal challenges. Contact us today for comprehensive HR support tailored to your business needs.
Gross misconduct dismissal allows an employer to dismiss an employee without notice, referred to as summary dismissal, where the misconduct is so serious that it fundamentally breaches the employment relationship. Common examples include: theft, fraud, violence, serious health and safety violations, serious insubordination, deliberate damage to property, and sexual harassment. What constitutes gross misconduct must be clearly defined in your disciplinary policy and staff handbook.
Even in cases of gross misconduct, the full formal disciplinary process must still be followed, including investigation, hearing, and the right of appeal. A summary dismissal without due process remains procedurally unfair regardless of how serious the misconduct was. Harwood HR manages gross misconduct cases from investigation through to dismissal, ensuring the process protects your business from successful unfair dismissal claims.
Harwood HR provides end-to-end disciplinary process uk support in the UK, from the moment you identify a potential conduct issue through to the final appeal outcome. Our support includes:
For ongoing disciplinary support, our retained HR service provides unlimited access to a dedicated consultant, available whenever a disciplinary issue arises, without per-case billing. For a one-off matter, our pay-as-you-go service provides expert support for individual cases billed by the hour.
Yes. Harwood HR Solutions works with each client to develop a disciplinary procedure tailored to their business structure, size and culture. This ensures the process is clear, fair and suitable for your specific working environment.
The typical disciplinary process includes investigation, formal notification of allegations, a disciplinary hearing and a final decision, which may result in no action, a warning or dismissal. Employees are given the opportunity to present their side of the story and can be accompanied by a trade union representative or colleague throughout the procedure.
Harwood HR Solutions supports businesses across a range of sectors including retail, manufacturing, professional services, healthcare, hospitality and construction. Each process is adapted to reflect the specific operational and compliance needs of the sector.
The duration can vary depending on the complexity of the case. However, Harwood HR aims to support clients in resolving most matters efficiently, often within a few weeks, without compromising on fairness or compliance.
Employees have the right to appeal any disciplinary decision. Harwood HR supports clients with managing appeals by reviewing the original process, providing an impartial hearing and ensuring the appeal is handled in line with the ACAS Code of Practice and UK employment law.
A consistent and well-communicated disciplinary process sets clear expectations and demonstrates that all staff are treated fairly. This promotes trust and helps retain employees, as they feel their concerns and conduct are handled professionally.
Yes. Harwood HR provides training for line managers and HR teams on handling disciplinary issues, conducting investigations and chairing hearings. This ensures internal processes are consistently followed and legally compliant.
Absolutely. Harwood HR can manage or support internal investigations, ensuring they are handled impartially and with full confidentiality. This includes gathering evidence, interviewing witnesses and preparing investigation reports.
Depending on your requirements, Harwood HR can support the disciplinary hearing process by advising on procedure, helping to prepare documentation, acting as a note-taker or assisting with appeals. In some cases, they may attend hearings as an external HR representative.
Having a clear and fair disciplinary procedure helps to build a culture of accountability and professionalism. When staff know what standards are expected and how issues are dealt with, it supports consistency and reduces workplace disputes.
All disciplinary support provided by Harwood HR aligns with the latest UK employment law and ACAS guidance. The team ensures that every stage of the process from investigation through to outcome is fair, legally sound and well-documented to protect your business from potential tribunal claims.
Organisations that fail to provide the statutory statement of main terms and conditions will breach the rights of their employee.
Read MoreWith us, you can create an easy-to-read company handbook that covers all bases. Our professionals guide and advise you on the best approach for your enterprise.
Read MoreWe make it easy to meet your legal obligation to provide a written statement to your employees detailing the precise terms and conditions of their employment.
Read MoreOur retained HR service offers you all the benefits of having your own HR department, but at a fraction of the cost.
Read MoreExperience the power of Harwood HR and unlock the exclusive H&S portal for just £20 per month.
Read MoreConvenient, flexible and affordable through our portal with NO upfront cost, employees will enjoy an enhanced learning environment.
Read More
Retained HR gives you ongoing support for a fixed monthly fee, best if you deal with HR activity most months or employ 10+ people. Pay-as-you-go HR support means you pay...
Read more